- Before
- “I can’t price a file that says the CFO earns one dollar.” Gets the census days after the RFP, still with assumptions the broker never agreed to.
- Now
- Accepts fixes a column at a time with the source of each in view, sends one message to the broker and signs quote-ready the same day.
One RFP, from the broker’s email to quote-ready
Monday, 07:42. Alyssa Ferrante at Kestrel Ridge Benefits Group sends the RFP for Corvane Precision Components: 440 rows of census, a 9-page letter and the current carrier’s plan summary. Quote due Friday 30 October. Here is the day, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 01Morning
The season’s RFPs, read on arrival
Nadia Brennan · Group underwriterNadia opens the queue: eight open cases, two due this week. Each row shows the employer and broker, lives in the letter against lives in the census, the lines asked for, the census fixes still open and the quote date. Corvane’s row already shows the problem in red: 600 lives in the letter, 412 in the census.
- 0207:42–07:51
The broker’s file, as sent — with every problem drawn on it
The agentsThe census opens as the spreadsheet it is: the broker’s own headers (DOB, DOH, Dept/Class, Sched Hrs) in grey above the rating field each maps to. The census mapper found the header on row 3 under a merged title, mapped 12 columns to rating layout v4 and dropped the SSN column. The data-quality checker read 440 rows and tinted 183 cells; the roster matcher matched 398 of 412 employees to the Ardent Shore billing roster.
“The census does not tell the same story as the RFP” — 3 of 3 differ.
- 0307:50
The letter, read into 22 plan fields — and checked
RFP reader · Census-vs-RFP reconcilerThe RFP reader turned the letter into plan designs for rating: basic life and AD&D by class, STD, LTD, voluntary term life, rate guarantees and situs, each field cited to its page. The reconciler’s margin notes show what each passage was checked against. Three differ: the letter says about 600 employees at three plants, the census has 412 with no Ohio ZIP, and the letter puts the current STD maximum at $1,000 a week while Ardent Shore’s plan summary says $1,250.
The reconciler never resolves a difference itself — it becomes a question.
- 04Row 4
Every fix shows its reason and its source
Nadia Brennan · Group underwriterTomás Reyes in sales support had already accepted the class and state columns at 08:56 and 08:57. Nadia clicks a tinted salary: Isaac Pettibone, as sent $27.00, suggested $56,160. The inspector gives the reason and the rule it came from, with Accept, Keep as sent and Edit.
“An hourly rate in the annual salary column. $27.00 × 40 scheduled hours × 52 weeks = $56,160.”
- 0510:21
One click, and 63 birth dates clear at once
Nadia Brennan · Group underwriterThe birth-date column has 63 problems: 50 values found in the current carrier’s billing roster, 13 two-digit years expanded. Nadia accepts the column and every tinted cell in it clears together. The quote-ready meter moves to 112 of 183 fixed.
“Birth date: 63 fixes accepted”
- 0607:51 · drafted
One message, with everything the file and letter leave open
Broker question drafterFour points in one email to Alyssa, copy Greg Halloran in group sales: send the Lima, OH census; which STD maximum to quote; sex for 7 employees — a rating factor the agents will not guess; and confirm that 14 employees scheduled 20 to 28 hours are not eligible under the 30-hour rule. Evidence attached: 4 passages, 7 rows.
Drafted by the agents, sent by you — nothing goes until Nadia presses Send.
- 0710:34 → 13:05
The broker answers everything at once
Alyssa Ferrante · Kestrel Ridge Benefits GroupNadia sends the message at 10:34. Alyssa replies at 13:05 with Corvane_Lima_census.xlsx — 188 rows, the same 12 columns as the main file — the seven missing sexes, and the answer on the STD maximum.
“The STD in the letter is a typo: the current maximum is $1,250 and Corvane wants to keep it.”
- 0813:07
The census now tells the same story as the RFP
Reply reader · Census-vs-RFP reconcilerThe reply reader matches the four answers back to rows and fields, the Lima rows are added to the grid, and the reconciler runs again. The banner turns green: 600 lives in the letter, 600 in the census; three plants in both; STD maximum $1,250, confirmed by the broker.
- 0914:20
Signed quote-ready, and sent to rating
Nadia Brennan · Group underwriterWith every fix accepted or kept, Nadia signs. The confirmation states what she is signing — 600 employees, 586 eligible, 3 plants, 22 plan fields, 183 changes on the log — and records her name, the meaning “Reviewed — census and plan designs quote-ready” and her password together.
- 1018 days early
What rating receives
Group ratingThe case summary goes with the rating file in layout v4: lives by class and location, ages at 1 January 2027, earnings and benefit volumes, seven readiness checks all passed, and every assumption in writing — how salaries were annualised, which birth dates came from the roster. Sent to rating 18 days before the quote is due.