- Before
- “I need to see why it moved a notch, and the page that proves it.” Owns the watchlist and chairs the weekly credit call.
- Now
- Opens each review on the notch ladder with every driver cited, asks the agents back, and signs with a reason code.
Counterparty risk management, one bank review screen by screen
Quillfield Capital reviews 412 banks and brokers a year. Selvira Yatırım Bankası, an Istanbul investment bank that four of its funds face in FX forwards and reverse repo, publishes its annual report only in Turkish — and its annual review is due Oct 30. Here is what happens, in the working solution.
- 01Monday, 09:05 London
What needs her, and what the agents did overnight
Farah Malik · Credit officerFarah opens to seven decisions awaiting her, 38 annual reviews due in 30 days, 14 counterparties on the watchlist and two limit excesses, both with a cure plan. Overnight the agents prepared 11 reviews and read 64 new filings. The agents' first line tells her the one decision that matters most today: Selvira's capital fell to 11.4% and the agents agree on one notch down.
“Ask me anything about a counterparty, a limit or a filing — I answer with sources, and I act when you tell me to.”
- 02Wed Oct 14, 06:12
A Turkish annual report, spread line by line
Spreading agentThe Filing Intake agent collected the 2025 Faaliyet Raporu — 248 pages, Turkish only — from the bank's investor relations site when the review window opened. The Spreading agent read it with the Pillar 3 disclosure and the BRSA audited statements into Quillfield's 184-line template, FY2024 beside FY2025, the Turkish label beside each line, at USD 1 = TRY 41.20. Three lines are flagged for the analyst, among them a restated FY2024 NPL ratio.
The Spreading agent never estimates a missing figure; restatements and reclassifications go to the analyst.
- 03One click
The page behind the number, original beside English
Farah Malik · Credit officerAny figure opens its source. Page 142 of the annual report shows the Sermaye Yeterliliği table in Turkish, with the CET1 ratio row highlighted — 13,1 to 11,4 — and the English reading beside it. The note says where the document came from and when it was received.
“The highlighted figure is the one the agents used.”
- 0406:20
One notch down, and a limit to match
Rating agentScorecard v4.2 gives 54.6, down from 61.2 — the QR14 band. On the rating notch ladder Selvira sits on QR13 with the proposed rung QR14 beside it, and each driver is an arrow sized by its push and weight: capital −0.55, liquidity −0.25, asset quality −0.30, profitability +0.10, market signals −0.15, a net −1.15 notches at confidence 0.91. The Limit agent reads the grid — $25M for a bank at QR14, below the $32.2M capital test of 2% of Tier 1 — and proposes $40M → $25M against $18.7M of exposure across four funds, with UCITS headroom checked fund by fund.
“No trade needs to be unwound. Below $50M, so the credit officer approves alone.”
- 0506:24
Six similar banks, one challenge
Peer agentThe Peer agent re-rates every proposal from banks of similar size and business model — here three Turkish and three Central European banks. Its peer-implied rating is QR14, so the difference is zero notches and nothing escalates. Selvira's CET1 of 11.4% is the lowest of the seven; the peer median is 14.3%. Asked, it re-runs without the development bank in the set and still finds QR14.
Any disagreement of more than one notch goes to the credit officer, with both arguments.
- 06Mon Oct 19
What changed since the report — and her question
Farah Malik · Credit officerThe Watch agent has added that Selvira postponed a $500M Eurobond issue, from a Turkish news item, and that its USD 2029 bond spread widened 86 bps to 498. Daniel Osei, the analyst, accepted the restated NPL ratio and submitted on Friday. Farah asks why liquidity counts against a bank whose LCR is well above 100%. The answer: LCR fell from 168% to 142% and NSFR from 121% to 114%, the steepest fall among the seven peers; the scorecard scores the one-year change, and it costs 0.25 notch.
- 0709:12 · signed
She signs with a reason code; then the limit system is updated
Farah Malik · Credit officerThe approval states what she signs — QR13 → QR14, limit $40M → $25M, prepared by Daniel Osei, with Farah as the checker. She picks reason code APR-01 “Proposal supported by the evidence” and confirms she has reviewed the cited evidence. Only then are QR14 and the $25M limit written to the counterparty master and the limit system, Kenji Watanabe on the FX desk is told, with $6.3M of headroom, and the next review is set for Apr 19, 2027 — six months, as Selvira is on the watchlist.
“Limit at or below $50M — your signature completes it.”
- 08Next on her list
When the agents disagree, she settles it
Farah Malik · Credit officerFor Banco Ribeira do Sul in São Paulo, the Rating agent proposes one notch up, QR12 → QR11, from a Portuguese annual report. The Peer agent disagrees: against six Brazilian mid-size banks it implies QR13, because the top 20 depositors hold 38% of deposits against a peer median of 21%. Two notches apart, it escalated to Farah with both arguments, and the analyst Sofia Reyes recommends keeping QR12. Farah chooses the rating and gives her reason.
Asked why the two agents disagree: “Scorecard v4.2 has no funding-concentration driver; it is on the list for v4.3.”