- Before
- Most faults are new to him, and the person who knew has retired. “The manual says change the motor. Somebody here must have seen this before.”
- Now
- Describes the fault and gets a six-step recipe with the retired fitter's note in the step that matters, parts by stock code and readings checked as he takes them.
One stuck tap changer, from the alarm to a fix the whole fleet now uses
Tuesday 13 October 2026, 06:42. SCADA at Lumina Utilities' Ashgrove Cross 132/33 kV primary substation raises “T2 OLTC — tap change incomplete”, then “Motor protection tripped”. The on-load tap changer on transformer T2 is a Corvane RS-III at 184,212 operations, resting between taps 9 and 10. Omar Haddad, two years at Lumina, is on call and has never seen this fault. The fitter who had, Graham Pell, retired in March 2025. Here is what happens next, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 0106:58
The fault, in plain words
Omar Haddad · Maintenance engineer, substationsOmar types what he sees: “OLTC stuck between taps, Ashgrove Cross T2, motor breaker tripped”. The open job WO-2026-171902 and the 06:42 alarm are already on the question bar. The run log shows the agents at work: the RS-III manual rev 7 read at §8.4 fault finding, §8.4.3 hand operation and §9.2 drive shaft; 186,400 work orders and 1,240 root-cause reports searched; the safety steps locked to SOP-SUB-031.
Manual and procedure searcher: “found a newer service bulletin — SB-RS3-11 (2019): coupling wear past 150,000 operations, not in the manual's table”
- 029.4 seconds later
A six-step fix recipe, every step cited
Fix recipe writerFive agents, 8 steps, 6 documents, 14 past jobs. The answer opens with the symptoms it matched — tap change incomplete alarm, motor protection Q1 tripped, indicator between taps 9 and 10, past 150,000 operations — then six numbered steps, each with its source. Beside it, Manual says · Field says: the manual's table 8-3 points to the motor; the field record says check the coupling first, test the motor, and leave it if it passes.
What was done, and did it hold? Coupling replaced: 0 of 9 came back. Motor replaced: 2 of 3 came back.
- 03Step 4
The retired fitter's note, in the step where it matters
Graham Pell · Senior substation fitter, retiredStep 4 says inspect the vertical drive-shaft coupling, gearbox end first, for a sheared nylon insert or a missing shear pin — on RS-III drives past 150,000 operations this is the usual cause, which is why it comes before any motor change. Graham Pell's job note from WO-2022-118734, on this same transformer, is pinned to the step. The safety steps, 1 and 6, are quoted from SOP-SUB-031 and the Safety Rules, not rewritten.
Job note · Graham Pell · 18 Feb 2022: “Replace the drive-shaft coupling, not the motor. Motor tests fine every time, it's the coupling insert shearing. Check the gearbox end first.”
- 04Why not the motor
Fourteen jobs, read from the technicians' own words
Work history minerThe work history miner read every closing note on this tap changer and symptom since 2019 and grouped them by the fix actually done: coupling replaced 9 times, 0 repeats in 90 days; motor replaced 3 times, 2 repeats in 30 days. At Oxley Road T1 the new motor was back in 9 days, at Kelbridge T1 in 11 — both times the next job found the coupling insert sheared. At Brayford T1 the motor winding really was open circuit, so step 3 still tests the motor.
WO-2025-166017, Hessle Gate T1, after Graham retired: “Took two calls to find someone who knew. Coupling insert. Replaced the kit.”
- 0507:05
The right part reserved, the expensive one left on the shelf
Parts and tools checkerThe parts list shows coupling insert kit 40-118-207 at $110, 4 in stock at Northgate depot, bin D-14-03, and shear pin 40-118-209, 12 in stock. The drive motor 40-118-150 at $6,200 is marked not needed. Omar reserves the kit against WO-2026-171902; three past jobs where this fix worked sit underneath — Ashgrove Cross T2, Fenmoor T1 and Asterdale T3, each done in about two hours.
Parts and tools checker: reserves only when the engineer asks, and never orders.
- 0607:40
The recipe becomes the job sheet
Omar Haddad, with Kofi Mensah · Authorised personKofi Mensah issued permit PTW-ACX-2026-0412 at 07:36: T2 motor drive cabinet, Q1 open, locked, notice fitted. Omar works through the recipe as a checklist. His motor readings come in from insulation tester IT-0447 — 210 MΩ and 4.3 Ω — and each is checked against the manual's range as it lands. Motor good, so the motor stays.
“✓ within the manual's range” · insulation resistance > 20 MΩ, winding 4.1–4.6 Ω
- 0709:52
Back on automatic voltage control, and the note writes itself from the readings
Knowledge stewardCoupling insert sheared at the bevel gearbox end; insert and shear pin replaced, grub screws at 12 N·m, step time 5.1 s. T2 is back on REMOTE and automatic voltage control at 09:52, 2 h 12 after the job started. When Omar closes the job, the knowledge steward drafts his closing note from his readings and finding and links it to WO-2022-118734 on this unit. The note is his to edit and sign.
Drafted note: “Second coupling failure on this unit in 4 years and 8 months: suggest a coupling check at each tap changer maintenance on RS-III units past 150,000 operations.”
- 08Signed 09:58
No note reaches anyone else until a reliability engineer reads it
Dr. Ines Varga · Reliability engineer, network assetsOmar signs and the note goes to Field fixes, waiting for Dr. Ines Varga. Beside it, the knowledge steward suggests adding this job to the RS-III field fix as its 10th coupling job. Ines can publish the note or ask Omar a question first. She publishes.
“Nothing changes in an answer until a reliability engineer approves it.”
- 0914:20
Field-proven, for every RS-III unit past 150,000 operations
Dr. Ines Varga · Reliability engineerThe proposal puts the answer today, which follows the manual's table, beside the proposed recipe, with the evidence: at least 3 jobs with the same fix — 9; none back within 90 days — 0 of 9; consistent with bulletin SB-RS3-11; safety steps unchanged, quoted from SOP-SUB-031. It changes the answer for 12 assets. Ines approves it as field-proven; she could instead ask the manufacturer to confirm or reject it with a reason.
“Approved by Dr. Ines Varga at 14:20. Answers now lead with this fix.”
- 10Before the next one leaves
Ask the next expert now, while she is still here
Doreen Achterberg · Senior process technician, Wexmoor water treatment worksDoreen retires in 66 days after 34 years on dosing, filters and pumps; 41 % of her 1,412 jobs have a usable note. The coverage map shows where her knowledge is written down and where it is not — filters at 29 %. The knowledge steward drafted questions from the gaps for her next session on Thu 22 Oct, such as what “as before” means on 9 high-lift pump 2 vibration jobs.
Session 1 · 8 Oct · 47 minutes: 5 notes drafted from the recording; Doreen has signed 3.