- Before
- “I don't need another calculator. I need to know which number will be questioned, and why it is right.”
- Now
- Asks the agents why, tells them what to change and approves it, decides the true-ups and the release with a reason code, and signs on day 5.
One quarter, worked with the agents, from the first message to a signed provision
Kestrel & Vane Group — 46 legal entities on two ledgers, a calendar year — ended Q3 FY2026 on Wed 30 Sep. It is Wed 7 Oct, day 5 of the close, and the provision is due to the corporate controller tomorrow. Here is how the tax controller works with the agents — asking, instructing, approving and signing — screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 01Wed 7 Oct, day 5
The agents tell her what needs her
Aisha Grant · Tax controllerHer home says it in one sentence: the Q3 provision is due to Daniel Okafor on Thu 8 Oct, the agents built it from 46 trial balances, the projected effective rate is 21.8%, and 5 things need her before she signs. Below, each agent writes to her in plain words, cites its sources and ends in a button: the $412K R&E true-up, Ireland's top-up tax near the threshold, a $655K release for Mexico 2020, 4 drafted auditor replies, and a roll-forward that ties.
“The R&E true-up is $412K, a change in R&D capitalisation … I propose you accept it in Q3 as a discrete item.” — Return-to-provision agent
- 02The rate reconciliation
Sixteen items tested against the 5% line
Threshold agentThe reconciliation is one table in the eight ASU 2023-09 categories, projected as the 10-K will show it. Pretax income of $642.0M gives tax at 21% of $134.8M and a 5% threshold of $6.74M. A threshold column shows each item's share of statutory tax. She selects Ireland's statutory rate difference, −$21,830K, and the agents on that line explain it: 16.2% of tax at the statutory rate, so it is shown on its own line, and the Irish profit of $256.8M comes from the trial balances of the two Irish entities and ties to the provision by jurisdiction.
“16 items tested · 4 own lines · 4 categories · 8 in other.” Every amount pins to its workpaper.
- 03The line to watch
Ireland's top-up tax, at 95% of the threshold
Threshold agentThe domestic minimum top-up tax is $6,420K, 4.8% of tax at the statutory rate, so this year it stays in “Ireland — other”, with $321K of headroom. If Irish profit beats plan by $12.8M (5.0%), it crosses. The agent proposes keeping it in other and re-testing on the Q4 forecast, with the own-line wording already drafted, and marks the proposal “Your call”.
“I will re-test when the Q4 forecast arrives and tell you the same day. The own-line wording is already drafted, so the 10-K does not wait.”
- 04One pin
The workpaper behind the figure
Aisha Grant · Tax controllerThe pin beside $6,420 opens workpaper W-RR-02.2: Irish profit subject to top-up of $256,824K, a top-up rate of 2.5% (15% less 12.5%), the $6,741K threshold and the 95% share. Below are its three sources — the workpaper Mateo Lindqvist prepared, the trial balances of KV Ireland Holdings Ltd and KV Ireland Manufacturing Ltd from S/4HANA, and ASC 740-10-50-12A — and the line's history.
History: “Threshold agent re-tested the line after the trial balance update.”
- 05In her own words
She tells the agent what to change
Aisha Grant · Tax controllerOn the other adjustments line she types an instruction: move the FX on tax balances to foreign tax effects. The threshold agent does not just do it. It shows a proposed change — re-test the line, update the workpaper, record the change on the audit trail — marked “Needs your approval”, with Approve, Edit and Reject.
“I can do that. Here is exactly what would change. It needs your approval, and I will re-run the 5% test and the tie-outs straight after.”
- 06Behind the numbers
The deferred roll-forward ties, four ways
Roll-forward agentBuilt from the trial balance and 61,204 fixed assets: every temporary difference from 1 Jan 2026 through the income statement, OCI and FX to 30 Sep, with fixed assets traced to the ledger by asset class. Capitalised research costs fell $12,920K as 2022–24 domestic costs were deducted under section 174A. Year-to-date deferred expense of $8,140K equals the provision, and the net liability of $4,260K equals the balance sheet.
“4 of 4 tie-outs pass.” The agents check each other before anyone signs.
- 07Mon 5 Oct, 14:05
Seven true-ups, each explained in plain words
Return-to-provision agentThe FY2025 returns against the FY2025 provision: 7 true-ups, net +$31K to Q3 tax, 3 that need her. The largest is $412K. KV Technologies Inc. claimed $1.962M of research credit, and section 280C, restored by the 2025 Act, says the R&E deduction must be reduced by the credit claimed. The provision did not reduce it: $1.962M × 21% = $412K more current tax, from Form 6765, Section G.
“It is a change in how R&D costs are capitalised and deducted, not an error in the credit.”
- 08Her decision
She asks why, then accepts with a reason code
Aisha Grant · Tax controllerShe asks why it was not in the provision: the FY2025 provision, signed 9 Feb 2026, missed the reduction for KV Technologies Inc., which joined the consolidated return in 2025. She picks A2 — Accept, explanation confirmed — writes her note and signs. The agent books nothing; her decision, reason and e-signature go on the audit trail.
Her note on the record: “Checked Form 6765 Section G and the section 280C computation; the provision did not reduce the deduction.”
- 09Due Fri 9 Oct
The auditor's questions, answered before she asks
Auditor agentThe agent built the Q3 request list for Halden & Ross from Q2's 31 requests plus 3 for what changed this quarter: 34 items, 29 ready before the auditor asked. Renée Castell sent 6 requests. Four have a drafted reply that cites its workpapers — the support for the Ireland 5% decision and the roll-forward tied to the balance sheet among them — and her question on any true-up over $250K waits for Aisha's R&E decision. Aisha approves and sends, edits, or sends a draft back with a reason.
“I share nothing until you approve it.” — Auditor agent
- 10Signed, day 5
She signs; the corporate controller accepts it into the close
Aisha Grant and Daniel OkaforThe sign-off shows what she is signing — Q3 tax expense of $35,212K, a projected annual rate of 21.8%, $101,320K year to date — and the 12-item close checklist the agents checked. Before signing she asks what is still open: none of it changes Q3 by more than the $500K materiality. She signs with S2 — Complete, with open items noted — and Daniel Okafor accepts the provision into the consolidated close for the 10-Q.
Her note: “Open items are below materiality and will be finished before Daniel accepts.”