- Before
- Flies three legs today, briefs each from a flight briefing package of coded NOTAMs, and has to trust that nothing on page 8 changes the flight.
- Now
- Reads the notices that change the flight in plain words, sees why every other one was set aside, and signs with a reason code.
One NOTAM briefing, from 238 notices to a signed acceptance
Corvane Airways CV 2207, an A321neo with 188 passengers, Denver to San Francisco on Thursday 15 October. Off-block 1835Z, ETA 2135Z, alternates Oakland and San Jose, release #3 signed by the dispatcher at 1615Z. At 1725Z a new NOTAM arrives. Here are the next ten minutes, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 011727Z
238 NOTAMs read, six that change the flight
Relevance agentThe briefing opens on the flight drawn as one ribbon: Denver, the climb, the route through HBU, MLF, ILC and OAL at FL360, the DYAMD5 arrival into San Francisco, and Oakland and San Jose branching off it. The ETA window, 2105Z–2235Z, is shaded. Six notices are pinned where and when they bite and listed below, ranked by impact: runway 28L closed at your ETA, no ILS glidepath to 28R, Denver 34L closed for your departure, Oakland ILS 30 out, GPS may be unreliable over Nevada, gate C10 out of service.
“232 not relevant to this flight — show me why.”
- 02Joined
Two NOTAMs, one consequence
Relevance agent!SFO 10/231, issued at 1725Z, puts the 28R glideslope out of service until about 0200Z on the 17th. On its own it is one more navaid notice. The agent joins it with notice 1: 28L is closed 2100Z–0600Z, the ETA is 2135Z, so 28R is the only west-flow landing runway, and it now has no ILS glidepath. The notice opens with the original text as received, its ICAO form, the decoded fields and each reasoning step, timed.
“Joined with notice 1: 28L closed and 28R has no glidepath — together they change the approach.”
- 031728Z
Every notice set aside has its reason, checked twice
Cross-checkerThe 232 NOTAMs set aside are grouped by reason in plain words: outside your time window 61, away from your route and airports 74, runways, taxiways and gates you won't use 39, not for this aircraft or operation 31, obstacles clear of your procedures 15, duplicates and superseded 12. The Cross-checker re-tested all of them against the nine always-brief rules and found no conflicts. It raised two close calls instead of dropping them.
Close call: “A crane 412 ft MSL, 1.1 NM west-northwest of the 28R end … Matters if you go around and cannot make the climb gradient, for example on one engine.”
- 041731Z
“What approach do we fly to 28R without the glideslope?”
Elena Brandt · First officer, A321neoElena asks in the briefing conversation, which cockpit and dispatch share. The Briefing assistant answers: expect RNAV (GPS) Z RWY 28R, or the localizer-only approach. Weather at 2135Z is wind 290/14, 6 SM in mist, broken at 1,500 ft, above the minimums of both; the A321neo is approved for LNAV/VNAV. Each fact carries its source — the NOTAMs, the chart, the SFO TAF and FOM 5.12.
The Briefing assistant never answers without a source, and never changes a release, a rule or a minimum.
- 051732Z
A go-around question finds the crane
Cross-checkerElena asks whether anything affects a go-around at San Francisco. The Cross-checker answers with the one set-aside notice that does: !SFO 10/196, the crane about 230 ft below the published missed-approach climb for 28R. It was set aside under obstacles clear of your procedures, and it says why it is still worth knowing. Nothing else touches the 28R missed approach.
- 061733Z
Promoted into the briefing, with a reason
Elena Brandt · First officer, A321neoElena promotes the crane with reason P2, it affects a contingency (go-around, engine-out, diversion). It becomes notice 7 for the whole crew and for dispatch. The assistant sends Hannah Okafor, the Briefing Lead, a proposed rule: brief obstacles within 300 ft of a missed-approach climb at the destination, not 200 ft. The rule waits for the Chief Pilot.
Agents never change a briefing rule themselves; the Briefing Lead proposes and the Chief Pilot approves.
- 071734Z
Dispatch saw it first and decides
Ruben Castillo · Aircraft dispatcher, desk 4Ruben was told at 1726Z, before the crew, with a 10-minute clock. The Change watcher and the Alternate checker proposed: keep release #3, since Oakland stays a legal alternate with a 1,200 ft margin, the SFO weather is above the RNAV and localizer minimums, and single-runway arrivals may add 10 to 15 minutes, and the 2,400 lb contingency covers about 29. Ruben chooses R1, no release change, crew informed, and the change goes to the cockpit on the EFB and by ACARS with his decision attached.
“Confidence 0.96 · two agents agree · the decision is yours.”
- 08Before signing
Both alternates legal in their window
Alternate checkerIn the alternate window, 2135Z–2335Z, Oakland's ILS 30 is out, so it qualifies on a non-precision approach: forecast BKN020 and more than 6 SM against the 800 ft and 2 SM required by FOM 7.4.2, a margin of 1,200 ft and 4 SM. San Jose is legal on the ILS to 30R; its shorter 30L is a close call, set aside because the plan lands 30R.
- 091735Z
The captain accepts the briefing
Capt. Dana Whitfield · Captain, A321neoDana opens Accept briefing. The acceptance lists the seven briefed notices with their NOTAM numbers, the promoted crane now notice 7. Both checks must be ticked by hand — read the 7 briefed notices and their original text, and seen why 231 were set aside — before Accept and sign can be pressed. She signs with reason A2, accepted with promoted notices.
“It is kept with release #3 for 3 months (14 CFR 121.695).”
- 10Signed
Four sign-offs and one evidence pack
Capt. Dana Whitfield · Captain, A321neoThe sign-off screen shows all four done: release #3 signed 1615Z, the dispatcher's R1 decision at 1734Z, the first officer's read at 1729Z, and the captain's A2 acceptance at 1735Z. The evidence pack holds all 238 notices as received, the briefed notices with their sentences and sources, every set-aside notice with its reason, the Cross-checker result, the conversation and every decision with its reason code.
One evidence pack per flight: 238 notices as received, 7 briefed, 231 set aside each with its reason, 9 rules checked with 0 conflicts and 2 close calls.