- Before
- Owns the spring campaign across six funds from spreadsheets and email, and finds out what does not add up when the LP report is already in draft.
- Now
- Opens four numbers and one next step each, asks the agents why a value moved, and approves each fund's dataset only when every check passes.
One fund's portfolio company ESG data, from a 340% outlier to an approved dataset
Quillfield Capital's private markets arm is GP to six funds holding 120 portfolio companies that report in 20 languages from 33 countries. The 2027 campaign, for FY2026 data, launched on February 1; companies confirm by Friday, March 26. It is Tuesday, March 16, 9:40 a.m. in New York. Here is what happens next, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 019:40 a.m.
Four numbers, one next step each, and a question for the agents
Claire Ashdown · ESG Lead, Private MarketsClaire's home shows 71 of 120 companies confirmed, 86% of values prefilled from documents (1,263 of 1,464), 23 outliers to explain and 0 of 6 fund datasets approved. Top of Needs you: Fennick Logistics, emissions intensity up 340%, the last open item in Quillfield Capital Partners V (QCP V). She types “Why is Fennick up 340%?” and the Outlier agent answers with the bill and the tracker cited: the Laredo cross-dock's 9 bills total 102,350 kWh, the tracker lists 102,350 MWh; corrected, intensity is 25.9, down 3.5%.
“The agents found kWh entered as MWh. The deal team explained; the correction is with Fennick’s CFO. It is the last open item in QCP V.”
- 02Prefilled, not surveyed
A French bill, read in French, cited to its page
Prefill agentThe confirmation grid puts companies down the side and the 13 metrics across the top: blue cells prefilled by agents and waiting for the company, green confirmed, gray missing, red outliers. In the European Mid-Market III fund, Atelier Dumesnil's electricity reads 3,391 MWh, prefilled at 92% confidence from page 2 of its French electricity report. The side panel shows the original sentence — “La consommation d'électricité s'élève à 3 391 MWh” — against last year's 3,332 MWh, a change of 2%.
Prefill agent: below 90% confidence it leaves the value for the company to answer; it leaves a value empty rather than guess.
- 03In the company's language
A confirm-only form, in German
Marcus Hartmann · CFO, Brandauer Verpackung GmbHCompanies never see the grid. This is what Brandauer's CFO sees in Quillfield's company portal: the form in German, each value already filled, each with its source — Stromverbrauch 27,640 MWh from the Nachhaltigkeitsbericht, Seite 14 — and two buttons, Bestätigen or Korrigieren. Six of 13 are confirmed. The renewable share of 61%, up from 18% because both plants buy guarantees of origin from January 2026, is marked as under review by Quillfield.
“Only the company confirms its values.”
- 04March 12, 7:06 p.m.
Fennick's Scope 2 cell turns red
Outlier agentFennick's facilities manager, Rob Haldane, uploaded an energy tracker on March 12: 124,728 MWh of electricity. The Carbon agent computed Scope 2 at 46,274 t against 8,165 t last year. The Outlier agent compared every value with the confirmed FY2025 dataset and 86 US logistics peers, flagged emissions intensity up 340% — 117.9 t per $M of revenue against a peer median of 31.2 — and routed it to the QCP V deal team.
Likely cause: “Units: one site's bills are in kWh but were entered as MWh (Laredo cross-dock).”
- 05The evidence
The tracker row beside the bill, 1,000 times apart
Prefill agentThe outlier page shows the jump against the peer band, then where it came from: Fennick's tracker lists the Laredo cross-dock at 102,350.00 MWh, while the nine Rio Bravo Electric Cooperative bills for the site total 102,350 kWh. The other 13 sites are billed in MWh by Gulfline Energy Services and total 22,377.65 MWh. 22,377.65 + 102.35 = 22,480 MWh. Laredo opened in April 2026, on a co-op that bills in kilowatt-hours.
Outlier agent: never changes a value; always names a likely cause and its source.
- 06Replay the check
How the agents reached it, step by step
Claire Ashdown · ESG Lead, Private MarketsClaire replays the check. Compared FY2026 with FY2025: intensity 26.8 to 117.9. Placed it against 86 US logistics peers: median 31.2, upper quartile 47.8. Ruled out growth: revenue up 5.9%, staff up 3.2%, sites 13 to 14. Re-read the bills behind electricity. Recomputed Scope 2: 22,480 MWh × 0.371 = 8,340 t. Routed to the QCP V deal team, Graham Holt and Mateo Ruiz.
Carbon agent: recomputes from activity data with a versioned emission factor set (v2025.1) and never overwrites a company figure.
- 078:55 a.m., then 9:45 a.m.
The deal team explains, and the CFO confirms in her own form
Dana Whitcomb · CFO, Fennick LogisticsMateo Ruiz checked with Fennick's facilities team at 8:55 a.m. and agreed with the correction; at 8:57 the Follow-up agent put it in Dana's form with the bills attached. Signed in to the company portal, Dana sees only Fennick: “One value needs your confirmation” — electricity 124,728 MWh struck through, 22,480 MWh proposed, Scope 2 8,340 t. She confirms, ticks the attestation and signs. The outlier closes under rule R-07.
Rule R-07 closes an outlier on its own only when the agents propose, the deal team explains and the company confirms.
- 089:47 a.m.
The fund dataset is approved, by someone who did not prepare it
Claire Ashdown · ESG Lead, Private MarketsTomás prepared the QCP V dataset at 9:12 a.m. — 24 companies, 312 values — with one open item, Fennick's electricity. With Fennick confirmed, all six checks pass — every company confirmed and signed, no open outliers, no missing values, every value with a source page or a signed company entry, no value changed after confirmation, units and boundaries checked. Claire approves with reason code DS-01. QCP V's Scope 1 + 2 is 148,589 t, up 3.6% on FY2025 — not 186,523 t, up 30%.
“Approval opens when every check passes. The preparer cannot approve.”
- 09From approved data only
The LP report section, every number cited
Reporting agentThe Reporting agent drafts the QCP V section of the annual LP ESG report from the approved dataset — climate, data quality, intensity, people, governance — with every number linked to its company confirmation and source page, including a plain note that one company's electricity was corrected before reporting. Claire asks where 148,589 t comes from: 62,595 t Scope 1 and 85,994 t Scope 2 across 24 companies, with Fennick at 8,340 t after its CFO confirmed.
“I never send anything to an LP.” Investor relations edits and marks the draft ready; compliance releases it.
- 10On the record
Every step, by people and agents, hash-chained
Gideon Park · Internal AuditThe audit trail holds the whole case: the Outlier agent's flag, the Prefill agent's re-read of nine bills, the Carbon agent's proposal with factor set v2025.1, Mateo's explanation, Dana's confirmation and attestation, the R-07 close, Tomás preparing as maker and Claire approving with DS-01 — each with who, which agent version, the evidence, the reason code and a hash. Internal audit can verify the chain and export an evidence pack.